New Yorkers and Americans thank New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani and appreciate his leadership following the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11. His efforts have clearly made the healing process that much easier for New Yorkers. However, as much as we appreciate him, Giuliani should step down as mayor and allow a new administrator lead New York City the rebuilding period.
Mayor Giuliani has recently asked for an extension of his term past Jan. 1, 2002. And though he is currently enjoying a period of unprecedented popularity, this does not allow the Mayor to subvert the political process. Granted, New Yorkers are facing rough times ahead, but if anything that is even more of a reason for them to return to normal. This requires letting the political process go forward as it always has.
Granting Mayor Giuliani an extension of his term would would require a complete change in New York election law. Term limits do not give him that option. Giuliani himself supported term limits referendums both in 1993 and 1996, so his decision to renege on his earlier statements might appear politically selfish to New Yorkers. Giuliani would also need the approval of other mayoral candidates, which he does not yet have. Bronx Borough President Fernando Ferrer does not support Giuliani’s proposal.
Mayor Giuliani should exit gracefully. Not only will this gesture show that he cares about New York, but it will also show he cares greatly about the political process. By stepping down, Giuliani will not only guarantee himself a good chance at future political office but it will also show New Yorkers that he has faith in who they choose as his successor to lead them in this time of national crisis.
Asking for time extensions, however, shows that Mayor Giuliani has questionable faith in the abilities of his successor. Furthermore, asking the mayoral candidates to support extending Giuliani’s term puts them in an awkward political position: they must either say yes or risk seeming uncooperative and unsupportive during this delicate situation. This is not good governance, and Giuliani should not sacrifice the long-term effects of the political process for short-term political gain.
Extending Giuliani’s tenure as mayor will ultimately hinder the rebuilding process. Giuliani’s successor needs ample time to familiarize himself with city affairs in order to make the best decisions regarding how best to proceed. However long Giuliani wants to extend his term?he currently is asking for a one month extension?the rebuilding process will outlive Giuliani’s term in office; therefore, Giuliani would best serve the city by relinquishing control and making the transition for the new Mayor that much easier.
