Trailer Takes: <i>9/11, Jigsaw,</i> and <i>The Mountain Between Us</i>

Trailer Takes: 9/11, Jigsaw, and The Mountain Between Us



Brynn: I don’t think I would watch this movie for free, forget paying to see it in theaters or as a rental. Aside from the fact that it will be a horrible Hollywoodized reduction of the tragedies that occurred on 9/11, the movie by itself just looks bad. The plot has the potential to be interesting but it is diminished by cheesy acting and lousy special effects. It is difficult to take the trailer even slightly seriously when each frame looks like it has been edited using the Instagram vignette filter. I doubt that even the presence of Whoopi Goldberg and Charlie Sheen can salvage the film. Having big-name actors might alleviate a minute bit of the audience’s suffering throughout what looks to be an awful movie but certainly won’t change the fact that the ratings will probably flop.

Eman: Oh. Haha. No, thank you. We’re all good over here and do not need this in our lives. But seriously, what was that? I don’t really have anything to say about this that won’t be the text equivalent of a blank stare. It’s quite obviously a paycheck gig for some of these actors (*cough* Whoopi Goldberg *cough*) who are either phoning it in or just as confused by the material as I am. I watched the trailer three times with the volume maxed out and still couldn’t decipher some of the dialogue. Even harder to decipher is the tone, which is not helped by the sheer incompetence of this trailer’s editor. Wow, even with what looks to be a poorly made film, one should still be able to string together an emotional journey through a trailer. But alas: failure. And how funny is that Inception-esque elevator sequence?

Dajour: My first thought after watching this trailer was, “why?” Why does this movie even exist? What purpose does it serve? Judging from the trailer, it does not look like the directing or the writing has anything worthwhile or new to say about the tragedy the movie is based on, so I’m struggling to see why this is even a thing. I’m not even sure who the movie’s target audience is and it seems that whoever put this trailer together isn’t sure either or simply does not care. The sound is off, the editing is mediocre at best and the acting – oh wow, the acting. Whoopi Goldberg is an Academy Award winning actress. Let that sink in. Above all though, the worst thing about this isn’t the terrible performances or editing. It’s the fact that this movie just looks pointless.



Brynn: Evidently, seven Saw movies could not encompass all of the horrific Saw traps to be conjured up by the twisted minds of the producers. Almost a decade after the movie series seemingly ended, a new sequence of blood and violence will hit theaters at the perfect moment, just days before Halloween. Because Jigsaw will be released right in the midst of the spookiest time of year, there is a better chance that audiences will actually make the effort to see this at the movie theater. However, at any other point in the year, I would tag this as a rental. The excessive gore is not unique on any scale, but if the “traps” are original at all there might be a dim light at the end of the tunnel for this film. The one redeeming factor is the plotline of Jigsaw’s character. I have minimal interest in seeing people’s necks sliced or heads bolted, but I am curious to find out how Jigsaw is somehow back from the dead (if he actually is). Aside from the possibility that the creators have done something fascinating with Jigsaw’s character development, there is little that sets this apart from the other cheap-looking horror films that will be watched for shocks and screams during Halloween season.

Eman: Contrary to its current perception, the Saw movie franchise actually started out as considerably high-brow horror. It was never really a perfect mind-bender or philosophical muse, but it played with audiences enough to keep the enthusiasm there, with some clever twists (both to the plot and to the human body). But as the franchise became a yearly thing, it grew stale, repetitive, and even a bit amateurish. However, the first sequence of this trailer was a thing of beauty. The rest is a hodge-podge of the good of the earlier films and the ordinariness of the later films. But at least it looks fun! There’s an honest-to-God laugh from one of the victims’ reactions to seeing the iconic Billy puppet, and many of the traps have a certain gonzo charm to them that should provide somewhat of a welcome change of pace to the usual “You have a bolt through your hand and you need to pull it off or Jigsaw will immolate you while crushing your head with a vice” kind of stuff. And there’s finally some variety in the settings as well, as the plethora of exteriors is nice surprise for someone who’s grown tired of seeing only tunnels and dungeons throughout the previous seven movies. Despite all this, I’m not completely convinced yet, but I’m a little bit more optimistic than I was before.

Dajour: I have managed to go my entire life without seeing one single Saw film in it’s entirety, partly because it never interested me and partly because I am a punk. It’s been years since the last one came out and I am not nearly as terrified by horror as I used to be. That being said, this trailer did not interest me very much. That might be because I have no connection to or knowledge of the prior Saw movies, but the trailer didn’t really do anything to set itself apart from any other incredibly basic horror movie that I have come to expect during October. The only thing the movie has going for it, and what I expect will get people into theaters, is that this is a Saw movie, something the trailer is not shy about. I will say though, if I was to see this movie it would be for the laughs. Rather than being scary, I actually found the trailer quite funny. The scene where the guy says “No, that’s not creepy at all,” after seeing the little puppet actually made me chuckle. And I get the sense that this trailer wants people to laugh. So, I’m not too invested in seeing this movie but I’m not entirely against it either.


The Mountain Between Us:

Brynn: I can already tell that I will spend the majority of this movie trying to figure out whether Kate Winslet or Idris Elba survives the plight back to safety. In my opinion, to let them both survive would be too trite but to kill them both off would be cruel to the audience. So, who will it be? Winslet, with her budding journalism career and fiancé back home, or Elba, with a family awaiting his return? I have a feeling Winslet, being a changed woman (and possibly having fallen in love with the man who helped save her life), will make it back alive and call off her wedding to pursue some neat new initiative. Then again, in the trailer, Winslet is the one who pushes to take risks to get to the bottom of the mountain while Elba wants to edge on the cautious side. I can see an ending where Elba survives, knowing that he owes it all to a woman who taught him to be bold and brave. Either way, there are bound to be gripping adventure scenes paired with classic Hollywood heartfelt moments that will make for an entertaining drama without being mind-boggling. I fully expect it to be ridden with clichés.

Eman: As a connoisseur of puns, I’ll give this one the thumbs up simply for the title. However, I do feel that the trajectory of the film that the trailer portrays may result in a passable but forgettable film. Idris Elba and Kate Winslet are titans of the acting craft and it would absolutely be a treat to see just the two of them versus the elements for two hours. But something about this rings a little too unextraordinary. Maybe it’s a touch melodramatic, or even predictable. Here’s my wishlist, though. If there’s even the least bit chance that we get to watch Kate Winslet eat Idris Elba in this film, then I’ll consider this movie the biggest win ever. Have you seen Alive? Go look it up. Let’s do that here. But now let’s say she eats him alive – as he encourages her to with his smooth accent. She’s as powerless against his accent as she is to the forces of nature. So she does the only thing she can: she prepares to eat him. A single tear rolls down Idris Elba’s cheek as he says “start with my heart,” because, ya know, movies. And without words, her eyes soaked with tears, all icy because, ya know, movies, she carves out his heart and devours it. And Idris Elba then offers her a soft smile as he slips into darkness forever, fading away with the cold wind, because, ya know, movies. Give me this.

Dajour: I love Idris Elba and Kate Winslet. They are both phenomenal actors and the idea alone of them being in a movie together having to play off one another is enough to make me want to see the movie. Unfortunately, that is the only thing about this that intrigues me. This trailer was incredibly dull. Even the big scene where their plane is crashing was just boring. There is nothing interesting about the way it is shot or edited and I don’t feel scared the way I probably should in a plane crash scene. It’s possible that that scene will be much more exciting in the actual movie, but for the purposes of this trailer it did nothing for me. As for the rest of the trailer, there just isn’t much to say about it. Nothing really sticks out. It’s not incompetently done at all, it looks like a very well made movie. It’s just completely forgettable. I’m struggling to remember what I just watched and that’s not a good sign. But, Kate Winslet and Idris Elba are in it, so I’ll probably still see it.

Image Credits: IMDb

About Author

Halftime Staff

Leave a Reply

@GtownVoice Twitter

Georgetown University
The Georgetown Voice
Box 571066
Washington, D.C. 20057

The Georgetown Voice office is located in Leavey 424.


The opinions expressed in the Georgetown Voice do not necessarily represent the views of the administration, faculty, or students of Georgetown University unless specifically stated.

By accessing, browsing, and otherwise using this site, you agree to our Disclaimer and Terms of Use. Find more information here: